Our cheapest offers for flights from New York to Iceland

Here you can compare cheap flights from New York (JFK) to Iceland for one-way or return trips. The following offers were searched for and found on idealo during the last few days. Or start your own flight search to Iceland. Prices and availability may change at any time.

Flights from New York (JFK) to Reykjavik-Keflavik (KEF)

	Outbound	Return	Airlines	Baggage	Price
Best option New York Reykjavik-Keflavik	Outbound 03/29/25 direct FI0614 05h 50min	Return 04/02/25 direct FI0615 06h 10min	Icelandair		$402
New York Reykjavik-Keflavik	Outbound 03/29/25 direct FI0614 05h 50min	Return 04/02/25 direct FI0615 06h 10min	Icelandair		$403
New York Reykjavik-Keflavik	Outbound 03/29/25 direct FI0614 05h 50min	Return 04/02/25 direct FI0615 06h 10min	Icelandair	?	$413