Flights from Indianapolis to New York

Our cheapest offers for flights from Indianapolis to New York

Here you can compare cheap flights from Indianapolis (IND) to New York (LGA) for one-way or return trips. The following offers were searched for and found on idealo during the last few days. Or start your own flight search to New York. Prices and availability may change at any time.

Outbound Return Airlines Shop Baggage Price
Indianapolis
New York
Outbound
12/06/25
1 Stopover (FLL)
NK0956, NK2858
10h 38min
Return
-
Spirit Airlines
$73
Best option
Indianapolis
New York
Outbound
04/03/26
direct
AA4468
01h 57min
Return
04/16/26
direct
AA4588
02h 20min
American Airlines ?
$329
Indianapolis
New York
Outbound
04/03/26
direct
AA4470
01h 59min
Return
04/16/26
direct
AA4593
02h 22min
American Airlines ?
$353
Indianapolis
New York
Outbound
04/03/26
direct
AA4470
01h 59min
Return
04/16/26
direct
AA4593
02h 22min
American Airlines ?
$425
Indianapolis
New York
Outbound
04/03/26
1 Stopover (MCO)
F91540, F92616
17h 59min
Return
04/16/26
1 Stopover (MIA, FLL)
AA1286, G40635
13h 16min
Frontier Airlines ?
$637
Prices based on recent searches, subject to last-minute changes
Page 1 / 1

Tips and tricks to help you find cheap flights from Indianapolis to New York

Favorite airline: American Airlines
The most popular airline for flights from Indianapolis to New York is American Airlines.
American Airlines
42 %
Delta
34 %
Frontier Airlines
11 %
Cheapest weekday: Tuesday
Compared to other weekdays, flights are cheapest on Tuesday.
Direct flights are more expensive
On this route, direct flights are $ 5.00 more expensive than flights with a stopover.
non stop flight
1 stop
02h 04min
12h 52min
$ 198
$ 193
The favorite connection is non-stop
82 % of all bookings on the route Indianapolis to New York are for non-stop flights.
Route
bookings
Direct flights
02h 04min, from $ 198
82 %
1 stopover Fort Lauderdale-Hollywood International Airport, FL
12h 52min, from $ 193
9 %
1 stopover Orlando International Airport, FL
24h 03min, from $ 233
6 %

Important flight information

Flight information: Indianapolis - New York

Cheapest outbound flight from $ 73,00
Roundtrip from $ 328,50
Flight duration min. 02:00 / max. 02:15
Return flight duration min. 02:29/ max. 02:47
Distance 1061 km
Flights per week 50
Departure airport Airport Indianapolis International Airport, IN (IND)
Arrival airport Airport New York - La Guardia Airport, NY (LGA)
Destination country Flights to United States
Alternative routes to United States
Alternative flights to New York
Flight destinations with a similar price
Flight destinations with a similar price