| Outbound | Return | Airlines | Shop | Baggage | Price | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| New York St. Thomas | Outbound 09/19/25 2 Stopovers (BOS, MIA) AA4659, AA2980, AA1391 19h 30min | Return 09/29/25 2 Stopovers (MIA, DCA) AA0943, AA2648, AA4551 20h 46min |  American Airlines |  | ? | $320 | |
| Best option New York St. Thomas | Outbound 06/18/25 direct AA2966 03h 55min | Return 07/15/25 direct AA2836 04h 25min | American Airlines |  | ? | $446 | |
| New York St. Thomas | Outbound 09/19/25 1 Stopover (SJU) B60303, B60936 16h 25min | Return 09/29/25 1 Stopover (SJU) B60435, B60504 16h 10min |  JetBlue Airways |  | ? | $339 | |
| New York St. Thomas | Outbound 09/19/25 2 Stopovers (DCA, MIA) AA4546, AA0422, AA1391 19h 02min | Return 09/29/25 2 Stopovers (MIA, BOS) AA0943, AA1054, AA4721 23h 08min | American Airlines |  | ? | $341 | |
| New York St. Thomas | Outbound 09/19/25 2 Stopovers (BOS, MIA) AA4397, AA0873, AA1391 17h 30min | Return 09/29/25 2 Stopovers (MIA, BOS) AA1391, AA1054, AA4566 18h 40min | American Airlines | | ? | $389 | |
| New York St. Thomas | Outbound 06/18/25 1 Stopover (MIA) AA1174, AA1391 21h 41min | Return 07/15/25 direct AA2836 04h 25min | American Airlines | | ? | $411 | |
| New York St. Thomas | Outbound 06/18/25 1 Stopover (SJU) B62903, B60936 20h 32min | Return 07/15/25 1 Stopover (SJU) B60435, B62904 17h 49min | JetBlue Airways | | ? | $428 | |
| New York St. Thomas | Outbound 06/18/25 direct AA2966 03h 55min | Return 07/15/25 direct AA2836 04h 25min | American Airlines |  | ? | $542 |
Tips and tricks to help you find cheap flights from New York to St. Thomas
Favorite airline: American Airlines
Most travelers looking for flights on the route from New York to St. Thomas decide to book flights with American Airlines.
American Airlines
67 %
Delta
25 %
Avianca
8 %