Our cheapest offers for flights from New York to St. Thomas

Here you can compare cheap flights from New York (NYC) to St. Thomas (STT) for one-way or return trips. The following offers were searched for and found on idealo during the last few days. Or start your own flight search to St. Thomas. Prices and availability may change at any time.

	Outbound	Return	Airlines	Baggage	Price
New York St. Thomas	Outbound 09/19/25 2 Stopovers (BOS, MIA) AA4659, AA2980, AA1391 19h 30min	Return 09/29/25 2 Stopovers (MIA, DCA) AA0943, AA2648, AA4551 20h 46min	American Airlines	?	$320
Best option New York St. Thomas	Outbound 06/18/25 direct AA2966 03h 55min	Return 07/15/25 direct AA2836 04h 25min	American Airlines	?	$446
New York St. Thomas Pay attention to transfer at connecting flight	Outbound 09/19/25 3 Stopovers (CLT, FLL, MCO) NK0207, NK1223, NK0676, NK0284 45h 36min	Return 09/29/25 2 Stopovers (MCO, FLL) NK0277, NK0675, NK2020 33h 15min	Spirit Airlines		$390
New York St. Thomas	Outbound 09/19/25 1 Stopover (SJU) B60303, B60936 16h 25min	Return 09/29/25 1 Stopover (SJU) B60435, B60504 16h 10min	JetBlue Airways	?	$339
New York St. Thomas	Outbound 09/19/25 2 Stopovers (DCA, MIA) AA3281, AA0401, AA0943 17h 20min	Return 09/29/25 2 Stopovers (MIA, BOS) AA0943, AA1054, AA1585 22h 41min	American Airlines	?	$341
New York St. Thomas	Outbound 09/19/25 2 Stopovers (BOS, MIA) AA4397, AA0873, AA1391 17h 30min	Return 09/29/25 2 Stopovers (MIA, BOS) AA1391, AA1054, AA4566 18h 40min	American Airlines	?	$389
New York St. Thomas	Outbound 09/19/25 1 Stopover (MIA) AA3237, AA0943 16h 50min	Return 09/29/25 1 Stopover (MIA) AA0943, AA2213 08h 56min	American Airlines	?	$390
New York St. Thomas	Outbound 06/18/25 1 Stopover (MIA) AA1174, AA1391 21h 41min	Return 07/15/25 direct AA2836 04h 25min	American Airlines	?	$411
New York St. Thomas	Outbound 06/18/25 1 Stopover (FLL) NK3396, NK0894 16h 57min	Return 07/15/25 1 Stopover (FLL) NK0867, NK3387 16h 28min	Spirit Airlines		$541
New York St. Thomas	Outbound 06/18/25 direct AA2966 03h 55min	Return 07/15/25 direct AA2836 04h 25min	American Airlines	?	$542

Tips and tricks to help you find cheap flights from New York to St. Thomas

Important flight information

Flight information: New York - St. Thomas

Roundtrip from	$319.69
Flight duration	min. 03:57 / max. 04:10
Return flight duration	min. 04:12/ max. 04:31
Distance	2640 km
Flights per week	15
Departure airport	Airport New York (JFK, EWR, LGA) (NYC)
Arrival airport	Airport St. Thomas (Virgin Islands) (STT)
Destination country	Flights to United States Virgin Islands

Alternative flights to St. Thomas

Flight Boston - St. Thomas from $252
Flight New York - St. Thomas from $320
Flight Atlanta - St. Thomas from $245
Flight Minneapolis - St. Thomas from $414
Flight Washington DC - St. Thomas from $526
Flight New York - St. Thomas from $341
Flight Washington-DC - St. Thomas from $526

Flight destinations with a similar price

Flight New York - Salt Lake City from $336
Flight New York - Sacramento from $293
Flight New York - Birmingham-Alabama from $323
Flight New York - Mexico City from $296
Flight New York - Antigua from $342
Flight New York - Aruba from $325
Flight New York - Lewisburg from $322
Flight New York - Staunton, VA from $322
Flight New York - Nassau from $337
Flight New York - Punta Cana from $313