Flights from New York to Montego Bay

Our cheapest offers for flights from New York to Montego Bay

Here you can compare cheap flights from New York (NYC) to Montego Bay (MBJ) for one-way or return trips. The following offers were searched for and found on idealo during the last few days. Or start your own flight search to Montego Bay. Prices and availability may change at any time.

Outbound Return Airlines Shop Baggage Price
New York
Montego Bay
Outbound
11/13/25
1 Stopover (ATL)
F94817, F90017
26h 38min
Return
11/17/25
1 Stopover (ATL)
F90016, F91872
21h 15min
Frontier Airlines
$373
Best option
New York
Montego Bay
Outbound
10/18/25
1 Stopover (FLL)
B62101, B61127
12h 40min
Return
11/17/25
direct
AA1349
03h 55min
JetBlue Airways ?
$437
New York
Montego Bay
Outbound
10/18/25
2 Stopovers (CLT, MIA)
AA1330, AA3184, AA3154
18h 06min
Return
11/17/25
2 Stopovers (MIA, PHX)
AA1277, AA2231, AA2476
28h 10min
American Airlines ?
$393
New York
Montego Bay
Outbound
11/13/25
direct
B60479
04h 04min
Return
11/17/25
1 Stopover (YYZ)
AC0989, AC8554
22h 29min
JetBlue Airways ?
$397
New York
Montego Bay
Outbound
10/18/25
2 Stopovers (PHX, MIA)
AA1282, AA2054, AA2300
29h 09min
Return
11/17/25
2 Stopovers (MIA, CLT)
AA1245, AA1596, AA1707
16h 55min
American Airlines ?
$400
New York
Montego Bay
Outbound
10/18/25
2 Stopovers (PHX, MIA)
AA2133, AA2054, AA3154
27h 07min
Return
11/17/25
1 Stopover (ORD)
AA1138, AA3355
22h 36min
American Airlines ?
$401
New York
Montego Bay
Outbound
10/18/25
2 Stopovers (ORD, CLT)
AA2644, AA1784, AA0875
18h 32min
Return
11/17/25
2 Stopovers (MIA, CLT)
AA1245, AA1596, AA1707
16h 55min
American Airlines ?
$401
New York
Montego Bay
Outbound
10/18/25
1 Stopover (MCO)
NK1801, NK1569
06h 21min
Return
11/17/25
1 Stopover (FLL)
NK0270, NK0179
09h 34min
Spirit Airlines
$406
New York
Montego Bay
Outbound
10/18/25
1 Stopover (MCO)
NK1801, NK1569
06h 21min
Return
11/17/25
2 Stopovers (FLL, MCO)
NK0270, NK0676, NK0916
19h 02min
Spirit Airlines
$409
New York
Montego Bay
Outbound
10/18/25
1 Stopover (MCO)
NK1801, NK1569
06h 21min
Return
11/17/25
1 Stopover (FLL)
NK0270, NK0179
09h 34min
Spirit Airlines
$411
Prices based on recent searches, subject to last-minute changes
Page 1 / 2

Tips and tricks to help you find cheap flights from New York to Montego Bay

Favorite airline: United Airlines
United Airlines is the most popular airline for flights from New York to Montego Bay.
United Airlines
25 %
American Airlines
24 %
Spirit Airlines
18 %
Direct flights are the cheapest connection
Compared to flights with a stopover, direct flights are $19.00 cheaper on this route.
non stop flight
1 stop
2 stops
03h 55min
06h 23min
16h 20min
322 $
341 $
368 $
The favorite connection is non-stop
Direct flights are especially popular on this route. 30 % of travelers will book a direct flight.
Route
bookings
Direct flights
03h 55min, from 322 $
30 %
1 stopover Charlotte Douglas International Airport, NC
14h 51min, from 500 $
26 %
1 stopover Orlando International Airport, FL
08h 07min, from 388 $
19 %

Important flight information

Flight information: New York - Montego Bay

Roundtrip from 372,24 $
Flight duration min. 03:55 / max. 04:17
Return flight duration min. 03:39/ max. 03:56
Distance 2505 km
Flights per week 42
Departure airport Airport New York, all Airports (NYC)
Arrival airport Airport Montego Bay (MBJ)
Destination country Flights to Jamaica
Alternative routes to Jamaica
Alternative flights to Montego Bay
Flight destinations with a similar price
Flight destinations with a similar price