Flights from New York to St. Thomas

Our cheapest offers for flights from New York to St. Thomas

Here you can compare cheap flights from New York (LGA) to St. Thomas (STT) for one-way or return trips. The following offers were searched for and found on idealo during the last few days. Or start your own flight search to St. Thomas. Prices and availability may change at any time.

Outbound Return Airlines Shop Baggage Price
New York
St. Thomas
Outbound
10/18/25
1 Stopover (MIA)
AA1249, AA0633
06h 50min
Return
11/17/25
2 Stopovers (MIA, DCA)
AA2056, AA2362, AA4664
18h 14min
American Airlines ?
$369
Best option
New York
St. Thomas
Outbound
10/18/25
1 Stopover (MIA)
AA2510, AA1391
09h 38min
Return
11/17/25
1 Stopover (CLT)
AA3200, AA1070
07h 48min
American Airlines ?
$453
New York
St. Thomas
Outbound
10/18/25
1 Stopover (FLL)
NK3396, NK0894
15h 49min
Return
11/17/25
1 Stopover (FLL)
NK0895, NK3387
23h 20min
Spirit Airlines
$373
New York
St. Thomas
Outbound
10/18/25
2 Stopovers (DCA, CLT)
AA4675, AA2882, AA2684
16h 54min
Return
11/17/25
2 Stopovers (MIA, DCA)
AA2056, AA2362, AA4664
18h 14min
American Airlines ?
$375
New York
St. Thomas
Outbound
10/18/25
1 Stopover (MIA)
AA2510, AA1391
09h 38min
Return
11/17/25
2 Stopovers (MIA, BOS)
AA2009, AA1054, AA4424
14h 13min
American Airlines ?
$593
New York
St. Thomas
Outbound
10/18/25
1 Stopover (IAH)
UA2606, UA1908
09h 43min
Return
11/17/25
1 Stopover (IAD)
UA1445, UA3497
06h 22min
United Airlines
$609
Prices based on recent searches, subject to last-minute changes
Page 1 / 1

Tips and tricks to help you find cheap flights from New York to St. Thomas

Favorite airline: American Airlines
The most popular airline for flights from New York to St. Thomas is American Airlines.
American Airlines
60 %
United Airlines
40 %
Favourite connection: via Miami
Stopover flights on this route are especially popular via Miami, making up 75 % of bookings.
Route
bookings
1 stopover Miami International Airport, FL
06h 46min, from $ 644
75 %
2 stopovers Houston - George Bush Intercontinental Airport, TX San Juan - Luis Muñoz Marín International Airport
11h 30min, from $ 1.048
25 %

Important flight information

Flight information: New York - St. Thomas

Roundtrip from $ 368,64
Distance 2639 km
Departure airport Airport New York - La Guardia Airport, NY (LGA)
Arrival airport Airport St. Thomas (Virgin Islands) (STT)
Destination country Flights to United States Virgin Islands
Alternative flights to St. Thomas
Flight destinations with a similar price